Dear Neutrogena, you need to fix your sunscreens

See also:

My top sunscreen recommendations

All the mineral sunscreens I have reviewed

Background

In the US there are severe limitations on sunscreen manufacturers and in order to provide UVA protection they can either choose between Zinc Oxide OR Avobenzone.

Neutrogena in their “Helioplex” formulation have chosen the Avobenzone route. Helioplex is synonymous with Neutrogena and my understanding is that it combines:

  • UVB filters (Homosalate, Octinoxate, Octocrylene) with
  • A UVA filter (Avobenzone – the only UVA1 filter permitted in the US) and
  • A UVA and UVB filter (Oxybenzone).

The Avobenzone is stabilised by Octocrylene, high amounts of Oxybenzone and most likely, other (for want of a better word) photostabilisers.

Without any doubt, Neutrogena sunscreens with SPF 30 and above, provide broadspectrum coverage and the presence of Avobenzone, ensures that this includes UVA1 protection.

Despite the above, out of the 39 sunscreens I found (in yes a CVS pharmacy), I’d only be comfortable with 3-4 products. These are:

Sunscreens featured are: Zinc Oxide 21.6% group (SheerZinc Face Dry touch sunscreen SPF 50, SheerZinc Dry touch sunscreen SPF 50, pure & free baby sunscreen SPF 50 (liquid and Zinc Oxide formula) and Neutrogena Hydro Boost Water Gel Lotion SPF 30

Most of these sunscreens, are Zinc Oxide 21.6% formulas. (For more details, please read “How to pay the lowest price for your sunscreen,” where I highlight the ubiquity of 21.6% Zinc Oxide formulas).

What’s my beef with Neutrogena sunscreens?

Oxybenzone.

Thirty four out of the 39 sunscreens I analysed, contained Oxybenzone (see Chemicals to Avoid – Benzophenone 3 for more details). BUT I wouldn’t have written this post if it was JUST Oxybenzone that was the problem.

Its this other group of similarly undesirable chemicals that find their way into many Neutrogena sunscreens.

The Undesirable Group

Table showing 5 undesirable chemicals present in Neutrogena sunscreens.  It also shows the no of products containing these chemicals

A) Five sunscreens contain Parabens

Parabens are hormonal disruptors that act as estrogen mimickers. (See “Chemicals to avoid – parabens” for more details). Neutrogena gets that consumers don’t want this obnoxious preservative in their product, as the other 34 products don’t have parabens. The paraben culprits are:

Image showing 5 Neutrogena sunscreens that contain parabens
Clockwise from top left corner (Sport Face Oil-Free SPF 70+, Ultra Sheer Dry Touch SPF 55, Oil-free moisturiser SPF 35, Healthy Defense daily moisturiser SPF 50, Ultra Sheer Dry Touch SPF 45

B) Eight sunscreens contain Methylisothiazolinone (“MI”)

MI is a preservative that the EU does not permit in leave on products such as sunscreens because its a contact allergen (see Note 1 below). In the US, MI is a preservative that is allowed in sunscreens, but this is under review. (See Note 2 below).

It’s also been named Allergen of the Year by the American Contact Dermatitis Society.

The MI culprits are:

9 Neutrogena sunscreens that contain the preservative Methylisothiazolinone
Clockwise from top left corner (Sensitive Skin Sunscreen Lotion SPF 60+, Age Shield SPF 70, Age Shield Face Oil-Free SPF 110, Oil Free moisturiser SPF 35, Ultra Sheer Dry Touch SPF 100, 70, 85+, Sport Face Oil-Free Lotion SPF 70+, Healthy Defense Daily Moisturiser SPF 35

C) Eighteen sunscreens contain BHT

BHA and BHT can induce allergic reactions in the skin and some evidence, suggests that high doses of BHT may mimic estrogen resulting in adverse reproductive affects. (See Note 3 below).

Eight sunscreens from Neutrogena containing the undesirable chemical, BHT
Clockwise from top left corner: Ultra Sheer® Dry-Touch Sunscreen Broad Spectrum SPF 30, 45, 55, 70, 85+, 100+ AND Clear Face Break-Out Free Liquid Lotion Sunscreen Broad Spectrum SPF 30, SPF 55
Ten sunscreens from Neutrogena containing the undesirable chemical, BHT
Clockwise from top left corner: sunscreen sticks (Beach Defense SPF 50+, CoolDry Sport SPF 50+, Ultra Sheer SPF 70), Sport Face Oil Free lotion SPF 70+, Oil Free moisturiser SPF 35, Healthy Defense Moisturiser SPF 50, Ultra Sheer Liquid SPF 70, Wet Skin kids stick SPF 70+, age shield face SPF 70, Age Shield oil-free SPF 110

D) Nine products also contain Retinyl Palmitate

RP is a Vitamin A compound, that has does not show significant anti-aging activity.

There is a raging debate about the risk vs. utility of RP. The concern is that topical applications of creams containing RP followed by UVR exposure can increase the risk of cancer. This study (by the National Toxicology Program) has been attacked from all quarters, including the unsuitability of the subject matter: hairless mice. I digress.

My guiding influence is (generally) the EU, that has said its OK with RP in topical applications but then quite sneakily says something like this:

“Retinyl Palmitate is not used in sunscreens and we have not considered its effect there.”

My position is this: the utility of RP is minimal and while scientists decide whether there is risk or not, I am not going to use it.

The RP semi-culprits are:

Nine products also contain Retinyl Palmitate
Clockwise from top left corner: Ultra Sheer Liquid SPF 70, Wet Skin Sunscreen Spray SPF 30, 50, 85+, Healthy Defense Moisturiser SPF 50, Ultra Sheer Sunscreen Spray SPF 30, 45, 70, 100+

E) Thirty four products contain Oxybenzone

Oxybenzone is a broadspectrum filter and is absolutely key to Neutrogena’s Helioplex formulation. The problems with Oxybenzone are well-documented (see also Chemicals to Avoid: Benzophenone-3).

Today, I wanted to highlight what the FDA’s current thinking on Oxybenzone is. The US FDA (February 2019) says that it needs more data about the safety of Oxybenzone (along with 12 other UV filters). It also said:

In biomonitoring studies of pregnant and lactating women, Oxybenzone has been detected in breast milk, amniotic fluid, and urine samples.

High levels of Oxybenzone in the urine of mothers have been associated with:

(1) Decreased birth weight in girls and

(2) increased birth weight and head circumference in boys, both of which can be indications of endocrine effects

It is estimated that Oxybenzone (from all sources – not just sunscreen) is present in the urine of 97% of Americans [4]

Sunscreen Drug Products for Over-the-Counter Human Use, A Proposed Rule by the Food and Drug Administration on 02/26/2019

If the above quote is insufficient to put the fear of using Oxybenzone in you, I am afraid you are on your own.

The products containing just OXB that haven’t been mentioned before are:

Multiple products from Neutrogena that contain Oxybenzone
Clockwise from top left corner: Hydro Boost Water Gel Lotion SPF 50 , Cool Dry Sport 30, 50, 70, Beach Defense lotion SPF 70, CoolDry Sport Lotion SPT 50, Beach Defense lotion SPF 30

That’s it for this week. Drop me a line if you have any queries or suggestions. ALWAYS happy to help.

P.S. Thank you Neutrogena for your excellent images available at this website Neutrogena

P.P.S. All data is accurate at 17th September 2019. I do not plan to review any of these products in the future, unless Neutrogena rethinks its strategy and uses anything but Helioplex in the bulk of its sunscreens.

Notes

Note 1: After finding sufficient data in European countries that showed MI was not only a contact allergen but also that there was increasing incidences of contact allergy to MI, the EU banned it in in leave-on products. (See this Regulation )

Note 4 115. Calafat, A.M., L.Y. Wong, X. Ye, et al., “Concentrations of the Sunscreen Agent Benzophenone-3 in Residents of the United States: National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 2003-2004,” Environmental Health Perspectives, vol. 116(7), pp. 893-897, 2008.

Note 5: A complete list of Neutrogena sunscreens in this blog:

Paraben containing products

Healthy Defense Daily moisturiser SPF 50, Oil free moisturiser with sunscreen SPF 35, Sport Face Oil-Free Lotion Sunscreen Broad Spectrum SPF 70+ and Ultra Sheer® Dry-Touch Sunscreen Broad Spectrum SPF 45 and SPF 55

BHT containing products

Age Shield Face oil-free Sunscreen SPF 110, Age Shield Sunscreen SPF 70, Beach Defense® Sunscreen Stick Broad Spectrum SPF 50+, Clear Face Break-Out Free Liquid Lotion Sunscreen Broad Spectrum SPF 30, SPF 55, CoolDry Sport Sunscreen Stick Broad Spectrum SPF 50+, Healthy Defense Daily moisturiser SPF 50, Oil free moisturiser with sunscreen SPF 35, Oil-Free Lotion Sunscreen Broad Spectrum SPF 70+, Ultra Sheer® Dry-Touch Sunscreen Broad Spectrum SPF 30, 45, 55, 70, 85+, 100+, Ultra Sheer® Liquid Sunscreen Broad Spectrum SPF 70, Wet Skin Kids Sunscreen stick SPF 70+, Sheer® Face + Body Stick Sunscreen Broad Spectrum SPF 70

MI containing products

Age Shield Face oil-free Sunscreen SPF 110, Age Shield Sunscreen SPF 70, Healthy Defense daily moisturiser SPF 50, Oil free moisturiser with sunscreen SPF 35, Sensitive Skin Sunscreen Lotion SPF 60+, Sport Face Oil-Free Lotion Sunscreen Broad Spectrum SPF 70+, Ultra Sheer® Dry-Touch Sunscreen Broad Spectrum SPF 100+ , 70, 85+

Retinyl Palmitate containing products

Healthy Defense daily moisturiser SPF 50, Ultra Sheer® Liquid Sunscreen Broad Spectrum SPF 70, Ultra Sheer® Sunscreen Spray, SPF 100+, Wet Skin Sunscreen Spray SPF 30, 50, 85+, Ultra Sheer® Sunscreen Spray, SPF 30, SPF 45, SPF 70

Remaining OXB products are:

Wet Skin Kids Sunscreen Spray  SPF 70+, Beach Defense® Sunscreen sunscreen lotion SPF 30, SPF 70, Cool Dry Sport Water-Resistant Sunscreen Spray SPF 30, 50, 70, CoolDry Sport Sunscreen Lotion Broad Spectrum SPF 50, Hydro Boost Water Gel Lotion SPF 50

***
Happy Skin Days ©  2021.  © Angeli Sinha 2021. All rights reserved. The contents of this blog, including images are protected by copyright law.  My content cannot be replicated without my consent. You can write to me at email@happyskindays.com

Leave a Comment

Subscribe to mailing list. Get a free book on blue ling too

Our site uses cookies.  By continuing to browse you accept our cookie policy